Today’s manufacturing and distribution companies face an ongoing challenge—how to balance labor flexibility with reliability. Companies increasingly look to workforce solutions like MyWorkChoice and Veryable to meet these needs. Each offers distinct advantages, but which is best suited to your facility?
This comparison will break down the differences, strengths, and weaknesses of both platforms, giving you the ability to choose the ideal workforce solution for your manufacturing or supply chain operations.
MyWorkChoice: Flexibility with Consistency
MyWorkChoice offers a unique model designed to balance worker flexibility with consistent, long-term employment, making it an excellent fit for manufacturing and supply chain industries. Here’s how MyWorkChoice can help solve your workforce needs:
Pros:
- Flexible Scheduling: Workers can choose from a full-time set schedule or select part-time shifts. This makes it appealing to a diverse labor pool, including traditional workers along with parents, students, and retirees.
- Consistent Work Locations: Workers are assigned to a single facility, creating familiarity with job sites and reducing training and onboarding time.
- Worker Benefits: MyWorkChoice stands out by offering benefits such as health insurance, W-2 employment status, and full Worker’s comp coverage.
- Engagement and Retention: The combination of flexibility, stability, and benefits leads to higher worker satisfaction and retention rates, which is critical for reducing turnover in industries with high employee churn.
- Fully-Manage Service: MyWorkChoice provides a complete program including all recruitment, scheduling, payroll and HR-related issues using both virtual and onsite support.
Cons:
- Shift Availability: While workers can choose shifts, availability can vary depending on demand, potentially leading to fewer options in slower periods.
- Headcount Limitations: MyWorkChoice is designed for entry-level roles at large manufacturing and distribution facilities. Companies looking for smaller additions to their headcount (5-10 workers), or who need short-term engagements (like an event or a few days of coverage) would be better served by a service like Veryable.
GE Appliances Enhances Staffing with MyWorkChoice
Veryable: On-Demand Marketplace
Veryable provides a just-in-time labor solution, ideal for companies that need rapid short-term staffing to meet fluctuating demand. Here’s what sets Veryable apart:
Pros:
- Immediate Labor Solutions: Veryable allows manufacturers and distributors to access a pool of workers on-demand, which is ideal for sudden spikes or short-term projects.
- Diverse Work Opportunities: For workers, Veryable offers work in multiple industries, which can broaden their skill sets and experience as they decide what career path to take.
- Earnings Potential: Workers have the chance to bid on jobs, potentially increasing their earnings, which can attract motivated labor for your production needs.
Cons:
- Lack of Stability: The on-demand nature of the platform means that work can be inconsistent, making it harder to establish a reliable workforce in industries like manufacturing that need steady labor.
- No Worker Benefits: Veryable employees are 1099 contractors and don’t receive health or other worker benefits. This may put companies and workers at risk for misclassification and workers’ compensation claims.
- Variable Work Environments: Workers move between various job sites, which may require more frequent onboarding and training due to a lack of consistency.
Comparing the Two Models
Both MyWorkChoice and Veryable bring something valuable to the table, but which one is the right fit for your manufacturing or supply chain operation? Here’s how the two stack up:
Flexibility and Stability
Both services offer flexibility, but MyWorkChoice excels by offering stable, recurring work environments. This can be crucial for manufacturers looking to reduce the downtime caused by frequent onboarding and training. Workers who return to the same job site consistently can integrate more efficiently, keeping production lines moving smoothly.
Worker Benefits & Retention
For manufacturers concerned with worker retention and well-being, MyWorkChoice’s provision of benefits like health insurance makes it an attractive solution. By offering benefits that are rare in the gig economy, MyWorkChoice fosters a more dedicated and reliable workforce. Veryable focuses more on short-term labor needs, with its bidding system catering to workers seeking immediate, flexible work, but this can lead to higher turnover rates.
Work Environment Consistency
MyWorkChoice provides a consistent work environment, which reduces the time spent training new workers. This stability is key in manufacturing and supply chain operations, where time is money, and smooth onboarding is vital. Veryable’s model, while flexible, involves more varied work environments, which could lead to increased variability in worker productivity.
Driving Innovation in the Face of a Changing Workforce
Support and Service
One of the biggest differences between MyWorkChoice and Veryable lies in their support and service models. MyWorkChoice offers a fully-managed service, providing end-to-end support that includes recruitment, scheduling, payroll, and handling all HR-related issues. On the other hand, Veryable operates on a self-serve model, where businesses are responsible for managing their workforce needs independently. While this offers greater control, it also increases the administrative burden, requiring internal teams to handle all aspects of workforce management, from scheduling to compliance.
Which Workforce Solution is Right for You?
For businesses in manufacturing and supply chain operations, your decision between MyWorkChoice and Veryable depends on your specific labor needs.
- MyWorkChoice is perfect if you prioritize worker retention, long-term consistency, and want to reduce onboarding times while offering benefits to keep your workforce engaged. This model suits businesses looking for steady labor to maintain predictable production rates.
- Veryable is ideal for companies that need rapid, short-term labor to meet fluctuating demand or seasonal surges. Its broad geographic reach and on-demand model provide flexibility but may lead to higher turnover and less worker stability.
- For companies seeking a more hands-off approach with comprehensive support, MyWorkChoice’s model provides a significant advantage, while Veryable is better suited for businesses that prefer to directly manage their labor force.
Both MyWorkChoice and Veryable offer innovative solutions to today’s workforce challenges in manufacturing and supply chain industries. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each helps you choose the best solution for your company’s unique labor needs.
As the demand for flexible workforce solutions grow, selecting the right partner is crucial to overcoming recruitment and retention challenges in the manufacturing and distribution industry.
| Feature | MyWorkChoice | Veryable |
|---|---|---|
| Employment Status | W2 Employees | 1099 Contractors |
| Workers' Compensation | Full Coverage | Not Provided |
| Tax Handling | Payroll Taxes Managed | Employer Responsible |
| Benefits | Potential for Employee Benefits | Typically None |
| Scheduling Management | Ful-Service Onsite Support | Self-Serve |
| HR Issue Handling | Managed by MyWorkChoice | Employer Responsible |
| Flexibility | Flexible Schedules with Consistent Availability | High Flexibility, Variable Consistency |
| Administrative Burden | Reduced Through Comprehensive Supprot | Increased Due to Self-Management |
| Control Over Selection | MyWorkChoice Handles Selection | Employer Has Direct Control |
| Cost Implications | Higher Due to W2 Benefits | Lower Due to Contractor Status |
Share